Healthy Homemade Butterfingers with Raw Manuka Honey
Recipes

Healthy Homemade Butterfingers with Raw Manuka Honey

Crispy, crunchy and delicious are how we describe these homemade Butterfingers. They have the same rich, chocolate flavor and crunch that you find in the real thing, but these are certainly healthier! Enjoy a classic Halloween treat...guilt-free!

Jump to recipe

As we gear up for 'candy season,' or, the month or so leading up to Halloween, we are bombarded with sugary temptations. From television commercials, social media ads and emails to store circulars and the aisles at your favorite big box stores, candy is everywhere. While delicious and enjoyable to indulge in, store-bought candy is generally full of sugar and not-so-good-for-you ingredients. 

While telling yourself 'no' to these temptations can be hard, it's even more difficult to say no to your children. Why not combat tantrums before they even start by preparing healthier homemade candy for the kiddos?

Butterfingers are a popular Halloween candy, and for good reason. They're crispy, crunchy and sweet. And, they're even better when they're homemade! Treat your children to candy with just a few ingredients.

This Healthy Homemade Butterfingers with raw Manuka Honey recipe was created by Rachel Mansfield of RachlMansfield.com and we're so glad she's shared it! This healthier twist on a classic candy is incredibly quick and easy to make. It requires just four ingredients and can be made in about an hour, including setting time. It's also gluten-free and dairy-free!

Homemade candy can be just as tasty at the store-bought kind, and, the flavors are easy to customize too. Want a little more crunch? A little less sweetness? Adjust the ingredients to your liking! It's also so satisfying to make your snacks by hand, especially when the kiddos join you in the kitchen.

This year, you're likely spending more time at home than usual. Pick a day to spend in the kitchen with the family and make lots of goodies from scratch, including homemade butterfingers! Make extra to enjoy throughout the month or package some up to share with friends and family. 

 We hope you'll test out this recipe and let us know what you think in the comments section!

Ingredients:

  • 1/3 cup Wedderspoon Manuka Honey 
  • 1 cup creamy nut butter (we suggest peanut butter or almond butter)
  • 1 1/3 cup brown rice crisps cereal
  • 1 cup dark chocolate

    Directions:

      1. Warm the Manuka Honey and nut butter over medium/low heat in a small sauce pan.
      2. Mix well until well combined (about one or two minutes).
      3. Pour mixture into a medium bowl and mix in the brown rice cereal. Mix to fully combine.
      4. Put the mixture in the fridge for about 15 minutes to firm up a bit.
      5. While mixture is firming, begin melting the dark chocolate in the microwave or on the stovetop.
      6. Remove the mixture from the fridge.
      7. Form the butterfingers by taking about 2 spoonfuls of the mixture into your hand and forming into a bar shape. 
      8. Place each 'bar' on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper.
      9. Continue steps 7 and 8 until you have used all of the mixture.
      10. Place the bars in the fridge to set for 10 to 15 minutes.
      11. When you remove them from the fridge, dip each bar, one by one, into melted chocolate. (We suggest using a fork and spoon to do this)
      12. Place each dipped bar back on the baking sheet and allow them to set for a bit longer in the fridge or freezer.
      13. If you have leftover chocolate, you can drizzle a bit on the tops of each bar before placing back in the fridge or freezer. 
      14. Enjoy at room temperature, or chilled.

    If you want to make these Butterfingers extra festive, consider melting a little bit of white chocolate and using food coloring to dye it orange and purple. Drizzle on top of the bars before setting in the fridge. 

    If you will not be enjoying these right away, you can store them in the fridge for up to a week, or in the freezer for longer....though we suspect these treats will be eaten up quickly!

    If you enjoy this recipe, we encourage you to try out some of our other homemade treat recipes, like Healthy Homemade Kit Kat Bars with Manuka Honey or All Natural Homemade Cherry Gummies with Manuka Honey

    Wedderspoon Manuka Honey is pantry staple, so make sure you don't run out! Stock up on your favorites.

      Shopping in Canada? Your favorite Wedderspoon products, including the Manuka Honey used in this recipe, are available in our Canadian online store.

      Read more
      Golden Summer Recipes
      Recipes

      Golden Summer Recipes

      Glow from within all summer long with these Mānuka sweetened recipes! From frozen sorbets to glazed donut holes, we're rounding up the recipes creators are making right now — each...

      Mānuka Honey Authentication Explained
      Education

      Mānuka Honey Authentication Explained

      The Truth Is on the Label—If You Know Where to Look You've heard the buzz about Mānuka honey. Maybe a friend swears by it for immune support, or you spotted...

      Lemon Raspberry Cheesecake Bars
      Recipes

      Lemon Raspberry Cheesecake Bars

      The Lemon Raspberry Cheesecake Bars are the perfect summer dessert! Made with Simple Mills lemon thin crust, creamy raspberry cheesecake filling, and buttery streusel sweetened with Mānuka Honey. Ingredients: Crust-...

      Healthier Cereal Treat Footballs
      Recipes

      Healthier Cereal Treat Footballs

      Powered by New Zealand sunshine and rich in MGO, Mānuka upgrades both flavor and function. Game day just got brighter with these healthier cereal treat footballs.

      KFactor to MGO, Everything You Need to Know
      News

      KFactor to MGO, Everything You Need to Know

      We’re transitioning from KFactor to the globally recognized MGO standard. It's the same Mānuka you love, now with a clearer way to understand its strength and the power behind it

      Meet the New Wedderspoon
      News

      Meet the New Wedderspoon

      The sunnier honey just got an upgrade! Wedderspoon, your favorite Mānuka Honey, now has a refreshed, brighter look.

      The Mānuka Mocktail Edit
      Recipes

      The Mānuka Mocktail Edit

      Dry January is here, and so is the hunt for drinks that still feel fun. Good news: Mānuka Honey brings smooth sweetness, natural depth, and a little sunshine to every...

      Save Your Winter Skin with Manuka
      Health & Wellness

      Save Your Winter Skin with Manuka

      Winter isn’t always kind to your skin, but Mānuka Honey’s soothing properties help support hydration and glowing skin.

      Why Manuka Honey Belongs in Your Sleep Routine
      Health & Wellness

      Why Manuka Honey Belongs in Your Sleep Routine

      Mānuka Honey’s slow-breaking natural sugars help keep blood sugar stable and quietly fuel your brain overnight, a simple way to support calmer nights and a sweeter sleep routine.

      The Sweetest Sleep Hack
      Health & Wellness

      The Sweetest Sleep Hack

      A spoonful of Mānuka Honey before bed can help steady blood sugar and gently fuel your brain overnight, making your sleep routine feel a little sweeter.

      10 Easy Lunchbox Treats with Manuka Honey
      Health & Wellness

      10 Easy Lunchbox Treats with Manuka Honey

      Back-to-school doesn’t have to mean boring sandwiches and uneaten snacks. With a touch of creativity, and a drizzle of raw Manuka honey, you can pack a lunch that brings a...

      Manuka Honey Face Masks: Benefits for Sensitive Skin
      Health & Wellness

      Manuka Honey Face Masks: Benefits for Sensitive Skin

      Manuka honey isn’t just for tea and toast. It’s a gentle, skin-loving ingredient that helps calm, hydrate, and brighten—perfect for sensitive faces craving a little extra care.

      Commitment to Clean: Glyphosate-Free Manuka Honey
      News

      Commitment to Clean: Glyphosate-Free Manuka Honey

      We strongly believe Manuka Honey is best enjoyed in its cleanest, most natural state. It’s perfect the way it is, created by mother nature, and authentically sourced from the lush...

      Celebrating Women’s History Month
      News

      Celebrating Women’s History Month

      March 1st marks the start of a very special month - Women’s History Month. This recognition month was initially recognized as a weeklong observance, starting in 1982. It then became...

      Cold & Flu Season Tips - Q&A with Ali Riley
      Health & Wellness

      Cold & Flu Season Tips - Q&A with Ali Riley

      The weather is getting crisp, the leaves are starting to fall to the ground and germs are beginning to spread more! We’re officially entering the start of cold and flu...

      Wedderspoon Celebrates Bee Aware Month
      News

      Wedderspoon Celebrates Bee Aware Month

        Apiculture New Zealand is the peak body representing the New Zealand apiculture industry. Apiculture is the technical term for beekeeping and the industry of raising bees and gathering honey. ...

      Preparing for a Smooth Transition Back to School
      Health & Wellness

      Preparing for a Smooth Transition Back to School

      The sun is setting earlier, the temperatures are starting to cool off and the local stores are filled with school supplies which can only mean one thing…Fall and the new...

      All-Natural Fuel, Anytime, Anywhere
      Health & Wellness

      All-Natural Fuel, Anytime, Anywhere

      Manuka Honey is considered a superfood because of its unique ingredients and wellness benefits. Among the many benefits of Manuka Honey are its ability to support the immune system, its...

      Wedderspoon Joins New Zealand Group Florenz
      News

      Wedderspoon Joins New Zealand Group Florenz

      We’re buzzing with excitement to announce that Wedderspoon Organic has entered a new phase of ownership and is now part of the newly-created New Zealand group Florenz!  We join other...

      Get to Know Ali Riley
      News

      Get to Know Ali Riley

      Last year we proudly announced our partnership with Ali Riley - professional soccer player, advocate and creator. A native of Los Angeles, Ali has played soccer all over the world,...

      Celebrating Pollinator Week 2024
      News

      Celebrating Pollinator Week 2024

      June is a very special month for those of us in the world of honey. Why so? Well, because Pollinator Week is recognized in the month of June. This year,...

      April Showers Bring May Flowers…and Allergies!
      Health & Wellness

      April Showers Bring May Flowers…and Allergies!

      Ease the Symptoms of Allergy Season with Your Favorite Wedderspoon Products Spring is in full swing…and so is allergy season! If you and your family are experiencing common spring allergy...

      Honoring Honeybees - World Bee Day
      Education

      Honoring Honeybees - World Bee Day

      World Bee Day is recognized annually on May 20th. This special day is meant to bring awareness to bees, their role in our ecosystem and the threats to their livelihood....